The decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Jones v Kernott is likely to have far-reaching implications for cohabiting couples and the ownership of property.
Mr Kernott and Ms Jones bought a house in their join names in 1985. They separated in 1993 following which Ms Jones was solely responsible for meeting the mortgage repayments. In 2006 Mr Kernott sought to realise his interest in the property which he claimed was 50%. Ms Jones argued she should be the sole beneficial owner of the property.
No declaration had been made as to who owned what at the time of the purchase. The question arose as to whether the conduct of the parties in the period following their separation was sufficient to change the shares of ownership in the property.
When the matter first came to court, the judge decided that it was and awarded Ms Jones a 90% share. Mr Kernott successfully appealed the decision in 2010 when the Court of Appeal indicated that ownership was equal.
Ms Jones then appealed to the Supreme Court which has now reversed the decision of the Court of Appeal and reverted to the decision of the original judge by awarded Ms Jones a 90% beneficial interest in the property, with Mr Jones having just 10%.
The Supreme Court decision has provided us with guidance on how the courts will approach a dispute of this nature. The starting point is still to consider what the legal ownership of the is (whether in joint names or one party’s sole name). However, whilst there is a presumption that the beneficial shares of ownership should follow the legal documentation, that presumption can be rebutted by evidence that it was not, or ceased to be, the common intention of the parties to hold the property in that way.
Where there is no clear evidence of the parties’ intentions with regard to ownership, the court will seek to infer a common intention by looking at the parties’ conduct and dealings with each other. However, the court will now go even further. In cases where the court is satisfied that the parties had a different intention as to ownership than the legal documentation suggests (either at the outset or subsequently) but there is no evidence to clarify what the shares of ownership should be, the court will determine what those shares are on the basis of what is fair having regard to the whole course of dealings between the parties so far as the property is concerned.
The decision has been hailed as a return to common sense and certainly provides more flexibility when there is a disagreement between couples as to who owns what. However, given that the court will now effectively impose intentions on parties who may well not have had them, does this go too far? Certainly, whilst there is now more flexibility there is certainly increased uncertainty in such cases and it is worth bearing in mind that Ms Jones and Mr Kernott have spent 6 years fighting this case through the court. They are not wealthy individuals and the property itself was of modest value.
The case certainly highlights the need for reform of the legislation to provide us with a clear framework in which to work. Couples should also think very carefully when they purchase a property how they wish to own it and ensure that they are given appropriate advice at the time of purchase. I would also strongly recommend entering into a cohabitation agreement to define the parties’ intentions clearly and concisely. The cost of doing so is a fraction of the costs of bringing court proceedings and will also provide peace of mind.
If you would like more legal advice on cohabitation agreements contact our family law solicitor Altrincham on 0845 0738 445 or email email@example.com
Latest MLP Law News
- June 16th, 2015What is a Deputy?
When someone has lost mental capacity and they do not have a Power of Attorney in place then you can apply to the Court of Protection to become that person’s deputy. This means that you will be authorised by the Court of Protection to make decisions on their behalf. This is extremely useful to families when they need to care for loved ones who aren’t able to look after themselves. What type of Deputy can I be? There are two types of deputy and you can apply to be one type of deputy or both. The property and financial affairs deputy will provide you with the power to handle such things as paying bills, organising a pension and buying food. The personal welfare deputy is able to make decisions about medical treatment and how someone is looked after. You may also be able ... Read More »
- May 21st, 2015Top 5 things to think about when considering a shareholders agreement…
What are the top 5 things you need to think about when considering a shareholders agreement? If you are considering setting up a company with family and/or friends or entering into a joint venture, you should consider putting a shareholders agreement in place. The company’s Articles of Association (it’s rule book) will give some basic guidance. Standard Articles will not deal with the finer detail so as to provide sufficient clarity and certainty as to what can, or cannot be done within the business. A shareholders agreement (which ideally ought to be put in place in the early stages) can: reduce the potential for conflict, lead to much greater protection of a shareholders investment, set out various guidelines as to how the business is governed and remain a private document. You should carefully consider the following questions before putting a shareholders agreement in ... Read More »
- May 20th, 2015New research shows unpaid invoices are costing UK SMEs thousands
Last year it was estimated that UK SMEs employed 15.2 million people and had a combined turnover of £1.6 trillion. These enterprises have an extremely important role to play in driving growth and creating jobs, and are often described as being the ‘lifeblood’ of our economy. That said, SMEs often face huge challenges, particularly concerning cash flow. Research we recently conducted found that, quite startlingly, SMEs in the UK are losing thousands of pounds and days of resource annually as a direct result of overdue invoices. We conducted the research in the hope that it would help shed some light on the extent of the cash flow problem in UK businesses. Indeed, latest figures from Bacs Payment Schemes found that SMEs across the country are facing a £8.2bn annual shortfall as a direct result of unpaid invoices. Our research attempted to delve deeper ... Read More »
- May 19th, 2015What should you do if you receive a letter from Getty Images on copyright infringement?
Getty Images, Inc. is an American stock photo agency who supply stock images for business and consumers with an archive of 80 million still images and illustrations and more than 50,000 hours of stock film footage. Since 2008, Getty Images has created controversy in its manner of pursuing copyright enforcement on behalf of its photographers. Rather than pursue a policy of sending out “cease and desist” notices, Getty typically mails out a demand letter claiming substantial sums of damages to owners of websites which it believes have used their images in infringement of their photographers’ copyright. So what do you do if you get a letter from Getty? First of all, are you guilty? For copyright infringement to take place, the owner of a copyrighted work will need to establish that either of the following acts are done in relation to a substantial ... Read More »
- May 13th, 2015General Election – Employment Law Consequences
In the aftermath of the Conservative win in the General Election, MLP’s employment team review the party’s pre-election promises for signs of what employment law developments may be in store in the next few years: Exclusivity clauses in zero hours contracts will be banned, although this falls short of the outright ban which the Labour Party had promised. The National Minimum Wage is set to increase to £8.00 by 2020, starting with an initial rise to £6.70 by November 2015. The tax-free personal allowance will increase to £12,500. If the 2020 National Minimum Wage increase comes to fruition, this will mean that people who work for 30 hours a week will pay no income tax at all. Entitlement to free childcare for working parents of all three and four year olds will increase to 30 hours. Trade union reforms are planned to prevent what the ... Read More »
- April 23rd, 2015#BeatStephen: We made it!
So that’s it – the marathon is over and this is my final #BeatStephen blog. It’s such a relief to say that we made it across that finish line and all our hard work paid off. Now I’m just trying to get over the pain in my muscles – something which was definitely expected after battling through those gruelling 26.2 miles. I was extremely nervous during the build-up between Saturday night and Sunday morning and I didn’t sleep as well as I’d hoped. But nonetheless, Sunday morning did arrive and it was soon time to make my way over to the starting line. My finishing time was four hours and 17 minutes, but I think I probably started off a little bit too quick. I completed the first ten miles in one hour and 33 minutes and the second ten in one ... Read More »
- April 7th, 2015#BeatStephen: The big day is nearly upon us!
There’s just two weeks left to go until the ASICS Greater Manchester Marathon and I’m certainly starting to feel the pressure. When I set foot out of the door on a cold and rainy Sunday for a ‘long’ three mile run in November, it didn’t feel like April would ever arrive. Sure enough, I set foot out of the same door four months, 20 weeks, 280 miles, 50 runs and one pair of shoes later into a very wet and cold Sunday morning for my considerably longer run of 20 miles. This time I start my runs feeling happier, lighter, confident and keen to get going. What a massive difference this is to when I first began my training! If you’re reading this and you’re running the Manchester marathon, or any other marathon for that matter, then I want to say ... Read More »
- March 26th, 2015Holiday Pay and Commission – what’s the latest?
Yesterday, an Employment Tribunal found that the Working Time Regulations 1998 must be interpreted as if it had additional wording which states that commission should be included in the calculation of holiday pay. This finding follows a period of uncertainty during which it was unclear whether UK legislation on holiday pay was compatible with a previous ruling made by the European Court of Justice that commission payments must be included in the calculation of holiday pay. It is therefore now beyond any doubt that employers are required to include commission in holiday pay paid to their employees. The difficulty at present, however, is that it remains unclear precisely how the commission should be calculated, including the reference period which should be taken into account when calculating commission for the purposes of holiday pay. However, whilst the Judge did not specifically decide upon ... Read More »
- March 13th, 2015Are you a fast growing business in the Technology, Media or Telecoms sector?
If you answered yes then you should consider entering our newly launched awards – ‘TMT Class of 2015′. We’ve set up the awards to recognise excellence within businesses in the UK’s dynamic Telecoms, Media and Technology (TMT) sectors. The awards are open to all businesses formed in or after 2010 that are thriving in today’s fast-growing digital landscape. We’re hoping that the awards will help us forecast what the TMT landscape might look like in 2020, and the businesses that are likely to shape its future, by looking at those that have set the bar high and excelled in their sector since inception. We’ll judge entrants on a number of metrics including innovation, creativity, key business achievements and future vision. The TMT sectors are elemental in the growth of our economy and we hope that the awards will help uncover some of the ... Read More »
- March 11th, 2015The importance of financial disclosure when getting divorced
According to a recent survey almost 25% of people seek to hide some of their assets when negotiating divorce settlements. The only reason for doing so is to frustrate a potential claim by the former spouse. Whilst the news comes as no surprise to any experienced family lawyer, it does pull into sharp focus just how widespread the problem is. I have lost count of the number of times a client has walked into my office to tell me that their other half has proposed to do things without solicitors “to save money”. This usually sets alarm bells ringing. In most cases of this nature we subsequently discover that there are assets or investments which were not known about at the outset, often of significant value. Full financial disclosure is vital to ensuring that any settlement is fair and reasonable. Quite often ... Read More »
- March 11th, 2015And the future is…MEDIATION!
Court proceedings can be very expensive and time consuming. Period! No matter how strong your case, litigation is never without risk. The Civil Procedure Rules which govern how litigation is conducted in England and Wales make it clear that court proceedings should be a last resort. Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution involving an independent third party (a mediator) whose role is to work with the parties at 1 venue usually during the course of a day, to achieve an acceptable settlement for everyone. This ends any existing court proceedings or avoids them completely. The savings achieved by a successful mediation in terms of costs and management time are enormous. We are experts in mediation. We know exactly what to do and when to do it. We will guide you seamlessly through the process from advising on the optimum time to mediate ... Read More »
- March 10th, 2015Rise In Court Fees – The Answer!
On 9 March 2015, the way in which Court fees in both specified and unspecified money claims are charged dramatically changed. Significantly, the fee to issue proceedings for the recovery of money on claims worth £10,000 or more is now 5% of the value of the claim, capped at a maximum fee of £10,000. So a claim for £20,000 now costs £1,000 to issue. This is a court fee increase of £390. A claim for £150,000 now costs a staggering £7,500. Previously the court fee was £1,315. Where the value of the claim is not identified or exceeds £300,000, the court fee payable is £10,000, a fee increase of £8,080! Whilst the money raised from these increases is reportedly going towards improving court services, the Ministry of Justice is already under pressure from The Law Society to rethink. In the meantime, savvy claimants coming to ... Read More »
- March 3rd, 2015Essential things you need to know about Design Rights and Registered Design
If you have created a new design of a product, you are going to want to protect it from others trying to steal your creative idea! We have summarised a few key things you should know to make sure your design is protected. What types of protection is there for my design? There are two types of protection for your design – design rights and registered design rights. Design rights are automatic whereas registered designs need to be applied for (both of these are subject to criteria being satisfied). What protection is given? Design rights provide the design with protection from copying for 10 years whereas registered designs are given 25 years of protection. What criteria needs to be met? For design rights, you need to satisfy the following criteria: The design must be a product (not a 2D design as these are copyrighted); and It must ... Read More »
- February 27th, 2015#BeatStephen: We’re halfway there!
I’m just over halfway through my training now and things have been going really well – I’ve been increasing my pace at a good rate and I’m even comfortably upping the distance I’m running regularly, too. Unfortunately though, I have learned the hard way just how much a simple cold can affect your training. I caught a bug last week and my progress had to be put on hold. When I started to feel under the weather, it really became quite a challenge to keep running whilst suffering with a sore throat and a blocked nose. I decided to give myself a few days off to recover, but it’s been a difficult one to shift and I’ve lost some vital running hours! Nonetheless, I’m now back on track and determined to carry on with increasing the distance. I completed a 12 mile ... Read More »
- February 16th, 2015Do house husbands get a raw deal on divorce?
Our head of family law, Theo Hoppen, asks: Do house husbands get a raw deal on divorce? Based on a recent family court decision, I would say “yes”. The court awarded Rupert Nightingale, a house husband and freelance photographer, a lump sum of £300,000 along with maintenance of £50,000 a year as part of his divorce settlement from his ex-wife. Mr Nightingale gave up his job 11 years ago to provide stability for the family and support his wife in her chosen career. He is also the main carer of their daughter who is at primary school. His ex-wife, Kirsten Turner, earns £420,000 a year as a partner at PWC accountants. The maintenance that the court ordered amounts to only 12% of her income and she can still afford to buy a £1.3 million property post-separation. The court ruled that Mr Nightingale in fact had ... Read More »
- February 13th, 2015What should SMEs expect from party manifestos?
It’s often said that small and medium sized enterprises are the engine room of the economy; for the UK to thrive, SMEs need to thrive. With the UK general election in sight it’s important for small and medium sized businesses, as well as entrepreneurs, to pay particular attention to upcoming party manifestos and what they will mean for SMEs. Although it’s difficult to know what they will say we can make some predictions to what they might include. At the start of 2014 there were an estimated 5.2 million businesses in the UK and small and medium sized companies accounted for 60% of this number. With more than half the business sector being taken up by SMEs the new party manifestos cannot fail to offer some significant pledges to help these all important enterprises. In this election year, the economic recovery is ... Read More »
- February 11th, 2015We’ve Been Nominated For Best Legal Firm Of The Year at the City of Manchester Business Awards 2015
We are extremely proud to announce that we have been shortlisted for Best Legal Firm of the Year in the upcoming City of Manchester Business Awards. Now in its fifth year, the annual awards ceremony celebrates the best of Manchester business. The event, which is hosted by Downtown in Business, will take place at Manchester Cathedral on Thursday 26th March. We are thrilled that our commitment to provide sound legal advice and an excellent service to our clients is being recognised. Just being nominated for such a prestigious award is fantastic and means a lot to everyone here at MLP Law. Having said this, we’d be lying if we said we wouldn’t like to win! We do have some tough competition to face though, as we’re up against the likes of Berg Solicitors, Freeths Solicitors, Gorvins Solicitors, JMW Solicitors and Shoosmiths. We value ... Read More »
- February 10th, 20154 Things Every Employer Should Know About LinkedIn
4 Things Every Employer Should Know About LinkedIn Use of the business social media tool LinkedIn is widespread, with an estimated 200 million users worldwide, with around 11 million in the UK alone. Many employers encourage the use of LinkedIn by their employees, having recognised the benefits it brings when trying to promote a business. However, what many employers are beginning to realise more and more is that LinkedIn is perhaps even more effective as a promoter of individuals. With this, come significant new risks for any employer, particular when their LinkedIn using employees leave. To help you understand the risks, we’ve put together a handy list of the key things you need to know about your employees using LinkedIn. Who owns the account? LinkedIn’s own membership terms state that the individual owns the account and that users must not let any third party use ... Read More »
- February 6th, 2015Changes to Rules on Company Names
On the 31 January 2015 new regulations came into force which simplify the rules relating to company names, it is intended that this will reduce the unnecessary regulatory burden on companies. Previously the Government had placed restrictions on certain words and characters that could be used, such as “group”, “holding”, “international” and “United Kingdom”. In addition the restrictions on accents, diacritical marks and ligatures have been reviewed. Now, should you wish for your company to use these words or characters in its name, approval is no longer needed. The new regulations also mean that fewer words are now disregarded for the purposes of deciding whether one name is the ‘same as’ another on the register including, but not limited to, “exports”, “group”, and “services”. This is designed to allow more choice for companies and to make name swaps within groups of ... Read More »
- January 30th, 2015What is a Power of Attorney?
There are different types of Powers of Attorney. Prior to 1 October 2007 Powers of Attorney were known as Enduring Powers of Attorney (EPA) and this document authorised an individual(s) to manage a person’s property and finances on their behalf. The EPA was replaced by Lasting Powers of attorney (LPA) on 1st October 2007. Whilst no new EPAs can be drawn up, EPAs signed before 1st October 2007 are still valid. If you are an attorney under an EPA then you may be using that EPA to manage a persons finances. One thing you should know about EPAs is that if you are acting under an EPA, and that person loses mental capacity, then it is your duty as an attorney to notify the Court of Protection. It is extremely important that you do this. LPAs are the new Powers of Attorney ... Read More »
- January 29th, 2015#BeatStephen: I’m Still Going!
It’s been a long and stressful week, and I must admit that keeping up with my training has been a bit of a struggle. I’ve been extremely busy at work and this has had an adverse effect on my motivation – the cold weather, feeling tired and working late isn’t conducive to early 6am starts. After such a demanding week, however, I feel more determined to get back into the full swing of the training programme. A good 10 mile run at the weekend with some friends helped me to get back on track. As I type this, I’m due another 5.45am start in the morning for a four and a half mile ‘comfortable’ paced run – although, I’m not so sure about the ‘comfortable’ part! I definitely feel like I’m improving slowly, so this certainly helps to keep me going. I ... Read More »