Challenges in Probate: Defending a contested Will
- Wills, Trusts & Probate
- 18th Dec 2023
The legal process of administering an estate after someone passes away, can often become a complex and emotionally charged undertaking, particularly when faced with contested wills. The challenges that arise during these disputes can test the boundaries of family relationships and legal frameworks. In this article, we explore some of the common challenges encountered in […]
By Samantha KennedyMLP Law
The legal process of administering an estate after someone passes away, can often become a complex and emotionally charged undertaking, particularly when faced with contested wills. The challenges that arise during these disputes can test the boundaries of family relationships and legal frameworks. In this article, we explore some of the common challenges encountered in probate and offer insights into effectively defending contested wills.
- Undue Influence and lack of capacity: A frequent challenge in defending contested wills is the allegation of undue influence or the claim that the deceased lacked the mental capacity to make rational decisions. Family members or interested parties may argue that the deceased was coerced into altering their will, or that they were not of sound mind when the will was created. Establishing the mental capacity of the testator at the time of drafting the will becomes crucial in such cases.
- Ambiguous wording and interpretation: Ambiguities in the language of a will can lead to disputes among beneficiaries. Vague or unclear terms may give rise to differing interpretations, causing family members to contest the distribution of assets. Resolving these issues often requires a careful examination of the testator’s intentions, considering the context and potential external influences.
- Family dynamics and disputes: Inheritance disputes often expose underlying family tensions and rivalries. Sibling rivalries, blended family dynamics, or disputes arising from unequal distribution of assets can complicate the probate process. Mediation or legal intervention may be necessary to guide through these familial challenges and find equitable resolutions.
- Forgery and fraud claims: Individuals may allege that the will is fraudulent or that signatures were forged. Proving or disproving such claims involves forensic analysis and careful examination of the authenticity of documents. Adequate documentation and witnesses become pivotal in defending against accusations of forgery or fraud.
- Executor’s role and conduct: The actions of the executor play a crucial role in the probate process. Challenges may arise if beneficiaries perceive the executor as acting against the testator’s wishes or in a manner that lacks transparency. Clear communication, adherence to legal obligations, and ethical conduct are essential for executors to successfully defend the probate process.
Defending contested wills in probate requires a delicate balance of legal expertise, empathy, and understanding of complex family dynamics. As these challenges can lead to emotional strain and protracted legal battles, seeking professional advice early in the process is often key. By addressing the issues of undue influence, ambiguous wording, family disputes, potential fraud, and executor conduct, individuals involved in probate can work towards a fair and just resolution, preserving the intent of the deceased and minimizing conflict.
Seeking Legal Advice
Our team understands the sensitive nature of probate and emotional challenges that can arise during such times. We are committed to guiding you through each step of the process, providing clarity. Whether you are an executor trying to fulfil your responsibilities or a beneficiary seeking to defend your rights, out team can provide comprehensive support and guide you through the process, working towards a resolution.
About the expert
Stephen is the Owner of MLP Law and leads our Commercial, IP and Dispute Resolution teams which provide advice on all aspects of the law relating to mergers, acquisitions, financing, re-structuring, complex commercial contracts, standard trading terms, share options, shareholder and partnership agreements, commercial dispute resolution, joint venture and partnering arrangements, IT and Technology law, Intellectual Property, EU and competition law, Brexit and GDPR.
Interested in working with Stephen?
Let’s start by getting to know you and your business - either on the phone or in person. Complete the form below and we’ll be in touch shortly.